The stolen Ife bronze

British police are protecting a stolen statue price tens of millions of {dollars} of their custody as a dispute rages between a Belgian vintage supplier and a Nigerian museum over its possession, writes Barnaby Phillips.

Short presentational grey line

Quick presentational gray line

The twenty fourth of January 2017 was a chilly, foggy day in London.

At noon John Axford, of the auctioneers Woolley and Wallis, was in his workplace in upmarket Mayfair, ready to fulfill a customer from Belgium who wished to point out him a sculpture.

“He produced this significantly lovely piece,” mentioned Mr Axford.

It was a bronze solid head, which Mr Axford recognised as coming from Ife, a Yoruba kingdom in what’s at this time south-western Nigeria. Authentic Ife bronze heads, of which just some 20 survive, are regarded as about 700 years previous.

They’re solid in skinny metallic with nice talent and are strikingly lifelike, amongst probably the most magnificent sculptures ever made in sub-Saharan Africa.

“This sort simply doesn’t flip up commercially,” mentioned Mr Axford.

However the sculpture had a gap by the left eye, which matched the outline of a head reported stolen by the UN’s cultural organisation, Unesco.

“I realised we had an issue,” mentioned Mr Axford. “If it was authorized, it might have been price £20m ($17m). I instructed the person it was a beautiful piece, however we won’t promote it. We needed to give it to the police.”

The stolen Ife bronze showing the hole near the eye

The bronze head was stolen from a museum in Nigeria in 1987

The person left. Mr Axford, afraid to let the sculpture out of his sight, slept with it at his bedside. The following morning he gave it to the British police, who’ve had it ever since.

To comply with this story to Mayfair, we should first return virtually precisely 30 years, to the town of Jos in central Nigeria. On the evening of 14 January 1987, thieves broke into the Jos Museum. A guard was severely crushed. The thieves knew what they wished – they made off with 9 of the museum’s most valuable treasures.

Within the Nineteen Eighties and ’90s Nigeria’s museums suffered many damaging robberies. Workers from inside Nigeria’s Nationwide Fee for Museums and Monuments (NCMM) collaborated in a number of the thefts. A former worker at Jos Museum instructed me she was in little question that this theft was additionally an inside job.

The NCMM immediately alerted Unesco, offering images of every part stolen from Jos.

In 1990 collectors in Switzerland have been approached by a person making an attempt to promote an exquisite Benin Bronze head for a half 1,000,000 Swiss francs. The collectors have been suspicious, and with the assistance of American, Swiss and Nigerian diplomat,s it was recognized as having come from Jos and was returned to Nigeria.

In the meantime the opposite eight items had, apparently, vanished. Most of them, together with the Ife head, are listed in a 1994 publication by the Worldwide Council of Museums (ICOM), entitled One Hundred Lacking Objects; Looting in Africa.

It wasn’t till a few years later, in weird circumstances, that the Ife head would reappear, in Belgium.

This photo is from the British Museum, probably 1947, when Ife heads were bought to London for an exhibition, before being returned to Nigeria in 1948. The stolen head is on the right, in the centre. (The BM took casts at that time, and with the cast were able to determine the authenticity of the stolen head in 2019).

Ife heads – together with the stolen one, which is on the fitting within the centre – have been delivered to London within the Forties for an exhibition

On 14 November 2007, the Belgian authorities held an public sale of confiscated artwork objects. Among the many heaps was the Ife head. It was purchased by a neighborhood vintage supplier, for the princely sum of €200 ($210; £170), plus 20% tax. He purchased an acoustic guitar on the similar public sale.

This extraordinary sale raises three apparent questions: how did this stolen treasure come into the palms of the Belgian authorities; why did they let it go; and did the supplier know he was shopping for one in all Africa’s best masterpieces?

Sadly, the Belgian authorities can’t throw any mild on the matter, however says the general public prosecutor’s workplace in Ghent has launched a judicial enquiry.

The Nigerian authorities are incandescent, not least as a result of Belgium’s failure to reply these questions could make it not possible to ever uncover what occurred to the opposite items stolen from Jos. Babatunde Adebiyi of the NCMM mentioned Belgium’s incapability to elucidate what occurred is “ridiculous”.

As for the vintage supplier, I managed to trace him down. We had a brief, terse phone dialog.

“Do you know you have been shopping for stolen property?” I requested the person, who we’ve got determined to not identify.

“After all I did not, I purchased it from the Belgian state,” he replied, and put the cellphone down.

Jos museum in 1970s

The pinnacle was stolen from Jos Museum (above)

The story then leaps ahead 10 years, to London and 2017, when the supplier tried to promote the pinnacle by means of Woolley and Wallis, who handed it on to the British police. In 2019 the police took the pinnacle to the British Museum, the place curators confirmed its authenticity by evaluating it with a solid that was made within the late Forties.

“I really feel assured it is real,” mentioned an knowledgeable who noticed it.

In any other case, the pinnacle has been sitting in a safe police facility for the previous 5 years. So why will not the British give it again to Nigeria?

That is the place the story turns into mired in authorized issues. The Nigerian authorities has asserted its possession declare to the British police, and raised the matter with the British authorities. It complains it has been handled “brusquely”. However the supplier refuses to relinquish his declare.

“Everybody agrees this piece was stolen,” mentioned a British official, “however has the Belgian supplier, in authorized phrases, finished something unsuitable? He purchased it in a authorities sale.”

"I told him [the antique dealer] he could be an international hero. He said he wanted money, not people saying nice things about him"", Source: Babatunde Adebiyi , Source description: Nigerian museum official, Image:

“I instructed him [the antique dealer] he might be a global hero. He mentioned he wished cash, not individuals saying good issues about him””, Supply: Babatunde Adebiyi , Supply description: Nigerian museum official, Picture:

The British police insist they’re impartial.

“No matter our non-public choice, we won’t take property from a person,” mentioned an official. “This must be resolved between the Nigerian authorities and the supplier.”

In 2019 a Nigerian delegation met the supplier. The ambiance, in keeping with Mr Adebiyi, was “cordial”. Mr Adebiyi pleaded with him. “I instructed him he might be a global hero. He mentioned he wished cash, not individuals saying good issues about him.”

The Nigerians say that at instances the supplier has requested for €5m, however has introduced his value down. British officers inform me he’s now asking for €39,000 (£33,500).

In our transient cellphone dialog, the supplier instructed me he is been speaking to the Nigerians for 3 years, and a decision of this matter relies on them.

However why ought to Nigeria pay to retrieve its personal stolen property?

“We reported its loss in 1987. We won’t pay compensation,” insisted Mr Adebiyi.

One attainable resolution, advised by the British, is that the Belgian authorities, having made the disastrous error of promoting the pinnacle in 2007, now repay the supplier. The Belgian authorities wouldn’t touch upon this, however instructed me that as Nigeria had taken Britain earlier than a Unesco advisory physique to attempt to resolve the case, it “continues to encourage dialogue” between them.

The present debate in Europe over colonial legacies, and particularly over African cultural heritage in European museums and collections, must strengthen Nigeria’s place on this dispute.

I requested Mr Adebiyi, given this piece’s worth, whether or not we must be involved about its safety ought to it return to a Nigerian authorities museum.

“1987 is completely different to 2022. Such a theft couldn’t happen at this time. Our officers are significantly better skilled,” he insisted.

Within the meantime, a British official assured me, the Ife head is being effectively taken care of.

“This can be a fabulous piece,” the official mentioned, “nevertheless it’s a travesty that it isn’t in a museum, and ideally the one it was taken from.”

Barnaby Phillips is a former BBC Nigeria correspondent, and the writer of Loot; Britain and the Benin Bronzes.

You may additionally be keen on: